Ernesto's Manifesto

Zero Credibility!

By Belligerent Bruce

The regular articles in the "Shepparton News" featuring interviews with community leaders about their views on climate change have in the main been informative and interesting, but the latest one on February 4th which features National Party MP, Damien Drum cannot go unanswered.

I do wonder if the views expressed in the article are actually Mr Drums, because they seem to come straight from the Coalition songbook.

 For the sake of this blog we will assume they are Mr Drums personal views. (You can access the article via the link below)

https://www.sheppnews.com.au/news/2020/01/31/1013427/shepparton-leaders-must-advocate-for-climate-truth

Let us look a little more closely at the article in question.

The headline screams "Australia leads way on climate change."

Nothing could be further from the truth, in fact a recent report from the 2020 Climate Change Performance Index handed down late last year ranked Australia as the worst performing country on climate change policy. You can read all about it by following the link below.

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/dec/11/australia-ranked-worst-of-57-countries-on-climate-change-policy?CMP=share_btn_link

Moving onto the article itself.

His response to question 1 "What is your position on global warming and climate change?" is little more than dogwhistling to his supporters.

He is saying there might be a link between human activity and climate change only insofar as the climate is changing anyway and he then gives credibility to the handful of "so called" scientists who say other factors are at play. "I also accept that there are many scientists who believe that there are other factors at play in our changing climate in addition to human activity."

This response is straight out of the climate deniers playbook and is rejected overwhelmingly by the vast majority of the scientific community.

Question 2 is "are we doing enough to mitigate the impact of climate change in the region?"

I have debunked the notion that Australia is leading the way among all other countries in the world earlier in this article.

His figures that we are leading the way in rooftop solar may be accurate but Australia is doing well in this area because of State Government incentives and individuals doing their bit, not because of federal Coalition government policy (or lack of). In fact the Coalition federal government has time and time again tried to destroy initiatives in this area like the renewable energy target.

Question 3 is about the role of business and community leaders in advocating for more action.

Below is a quote from the article.

"Our electricity and gas costs, both at a domestic and commercial/industrial level, have already risen significantly as we transition away from fossil fuels towards renewable energy. We need to be mindful that it is often the poorest families in our communities who often live in the least energy-efficient homes"

Here Mr Drum is effectively blaming the transition from fossil fuels to renewables for high power prices whereas the reality is renewables are keeping power prices from rising exponentially. 

Mr Drum goes on to say it is up to community and business leaders to advocate for the truth to find its way into mainstream media. 

This, coming from a member of a Coalition government who continually pedal lies about climate change?

If it wasn't so serious it would be laughable.

A cavalcade of Government ministers including our Pentecostal PM have gone on mainstream media month after month to push the lie that our carbon emissions are falling and we will meet our (inadequate) Paris targets "in a canter" despite the governments own departments figures showing our emissions are rising, and we have to cheat by using clever accounting methods to meet those Paris targets by using so called "Kyoto Credits".

And who can remember Tony Abbotts lies about the cost of power going down by $550 pa when this shortsighted coal loving government scrapped the price on Carbon?

If it is up to business and community leaders to ensure the truth gets reported on mainstream media, why doesn't the PM and his government set an example themselves and start telling the truth?

Finally Mr Drums number one priority to help mitigate impacts of climate change is "to push the fact that Australia is leading the way", so his main response is to continue to push a lie?

His comments on agriculture and having less water in a drier environment are all well and good but then he advocates taking more water from the environment for farmers .

The disaster of the Darling River should be enough for most thinking people to understand that we need more water for the environment, not less. 

Without a healthy river system we have no agriculture! Think about what that means for the Shepparton region.

There is growing scientific consensus that even if all countries meet their Paris emission targets, the planet is in for a 3 to 4 degree rise in temperature so more aggressive emission reduction targets will have to be set soon if we are to have a chance of avoiding this scenario. Meanwhile members in Mr Drums party are pushing for new coal fired power generators.

The National and Liberal parties need to stop believing and regurgitating the lies of the flat earthers in the Murdoch press and the Minerals Council of Australia and stand up for what is the right course of action for Australia and the planet.

Until they do that they will have zero credibility.