With their finals hopes in the balance, the Sea Eagles chose to persist with donning the Everyone In League strip, which replaces Manly's traditional white hoops with the rainbow pattern the LGBTQIA+ community has made its own.
The preamble to the game was indistinguishable from any other Thursday night match in Brookvale, the Sea Eagles and Sydney Roosters warming up and broadcast crews capturing the scene.
But the differences were to be seen in the average-sized crowd of 12,187, where passionate Manly fans showed their pride.
Manly's merchandise store inside the stadium sold out of men's sizes of the Everyone In League jersey within 20 minutes of opening, and women's sizes in 30 minutes.
Employee Kayla said it was the first time she could remember a jersey selling out on game day.
"It's such good vibes," she said.
"We usually only ever sell out of things on cold nights, like scarves and beanies."
Manly's Seabirds cheerleaders mingled with fans on entry wearing rainbow patterns in their outfits, while some punters took their seats, rainbow flags and signs in hand.
Long-time Sea Eagles fan Mark said the week of headlines motivated him to go out and buy the inclusion-themed jersey, which sold out online in the lead-up to game day.
"Dessie (coach Des Hasler) and DCE (captain Daly Cherry-Evans) at the press conference, they handled it really well and I thought I should show some support for them," he said.
"We're all in this stadium together, we share it together and we breathe the same air.
"Do we want to go backwards or do we want to take the opportunity to look forwards?"
Manly fans Ava, Emilia and Jade said the result of Thursday night's game mattered less than the club's decision to persist with wearing the first-of-its-kind pride strip.
"I wanted to get the Pride jersey," Ava said. "We support the cause. I was pretty chuffed to hear we were the first to do it. Now's the time."
Sea Eagles supporter Belinda hadn't been to a game in over 10 years by her own estimation but came along with her daughter Zoe.
"We came to support the cause, to support the team and to support the new guys," she said.
Maafu Palu, pastor at a Tongan church in Sydney's west, came to the game in a group supporting the seven players who chose not to wear the jerseys on religious grounds.
"We trust very much in the bible as the word of God, so when I hear about these guys making a stand, I can understand," Palu told AAP.
"I'm happy for those who are supportive of the LGBTQIA+ community. In Tonga, we live with a very good relationship with people of all kinds.
"These rainbow colours stand for diversity but it should include everyone, not just everyone except Christians."
During the week, openly gay NRL great Ian Roberts said he would be open to meeting the players who sat out to discuss the significance of a pride round.
"Knowing Pacific Islanders, I'm sure they'd be open to talking to anybody about this sort of thing," Palu said.
