Nearly two years on, much has changed.
One name was called out as the final pick in the first round of the 2024 AFL National Draft, presented his new colours on stage.
The other name was heard through the television at the Shepparton football clubrooms the next night, celebrated with friends and family on Year 12 graduation.
But once the draft day dust settled, life was fast to shift for the Whitlock twins.
One moved into Melbourne’s city life, the other across state borders to Alberton, South Australia.
While always returning to the Goulburn Valley where possible - such as at the weekend during North Melbourne and Port Adelaide’s round 12 byes - the two-metre talls have settled right in at their homes away from home.
Speaking on the latest episode of the News’ Media Fines podcast, the Whitlock brothers reflected on the change in scenery as they forge a promising start to their burgeoning careers at the top flight.
“You go from studying in Year 12 and being super busy, and then you get drafted and three days later you’re on a flight and you’re moving interstate,” Jack said.
“I think with footy, the lucky thing is you’re used to the busyness and the structure of school, which is sort of what you still get with footy.
“But I was settling into a state where I think I’d only ever been to once for a day trip... I knew nothing about the city really.
“I was lucky enough to go with (Benalla product) Joe Berry, who I already had a pretty good relationship with... but it took a bit (to settle in).”
Two hours south of Shepparton, Matt still has a taste of home, living with Shepparton United export and Melbourne Demons draftee Riley Onley as well as another mate studying at university this year.
While Jack has exploded in his second year of football, earning a Rising Star nomination in round eight and yet to miss a senior selection this season, it was Matt who first earned a debut, in round four, 2025.
“When I first got drafted, I remember in the pre-season I just wanted to do everything I could to crack into that side and hopefully contribute,” Matt said.
“I was lucky enough to play some good VFL down back and to earn my debut was a huge honour, I’m forever grateful for that experience.
“I remember walking out, going through the race and taking it all in.
“From being a little kid to being where I am now, it was such a cool experience.”
Jack’s debut came in round 21 against Geelong at the Cats’ home ground, with the Power forward reminiscing on seeing dozens of friends and family turn out for the clash.
“I would’ve had maybe 30 tickets for family and probably about 30 friends there,” he said.
“We all went to the pub after the game so it was a good night.”
Two weeks later, and the boys would share a special weekend, both kicking their first career goals in round 23.
“They switched me up forward for the last few weeks of the year to see how I’d go up there, and I had one that fell in my lap and I ran into the goal square and celebrated pretty hard,” Matt said, laughing upon reflection.
“And obviously with Jack kicking his goal then as well, it’s good to look back on those things and reflect, it was nice.”
But in among the bright lights of AFL stardom, there is still a humble love for the Goulburn Valley.
In the pair’s short stay over the bye, a game of golf at Hill Top in Tatura - with some financial stakes on the line - was early on the weekend agenda.
The twins confirmed keeping a watchful eye on the Goulburn Valley League is still a top priority too, with some friendly competition at either club.
“I’m living with Joe Berry at the moment, so he’s a Benalla boy, we usually have it on every Saturday, whatever game is being streamed,” Jack said.
“I’m super stoked with how the Bears have started their season with (co-coach) Jason Wells, who both Matt and I have had a pretty good relationship with over the past few years, with him being forwards coach at Bushies.”
“I still keep track as well,” Matt added.
“It’s funny, Micky Barlow the midfield coach (at North Melbourne), we give a bit of stick to each other since he’s at United now... spewing I can’t watch him!”
While Shepparton will always be home, the Whitlocks are evidently relishing the life of a professional athlete - Jack is flying under the tutelage of Port Adelaide senior coach Josh Carr and Matt is bashing down the selection door with his efforts as a key forward in the VFL.
So, perhaps for the best, it may be a long time between drinks on Deakin Reserve for Matt and Jack Whitlock.
Listen to the full Media Fines chat with Matt and Jack Whitlock on the The News website.
