Emma Bates died at her Cobram home in April 2024.
Photo by
Contributed
A man has pushed for his negligent manslaughter charge to be dropped, arguing he did not hold a duty of care for a woman who died.
Hold tight - we’re checking permissions before loading more content
Emma Bates, 49, was found dead at her home in Cobram on April 23, 2024.
She had allegedly been struck to the head by her neighbour and short-term partner John Torney, 40, in the days before she died.
But a forensic pathologist told Melbourne Magistrates’ Court diabetic ketoacidosis, a condition involving high sugar levels, was the likely cause of her death.
Prosecutor Matthew Cookson on Wednesday, November 5, argued Mr Torney still owed a duty of care to Ms Bates because they were in a de facto relationship, given they were intimate and living together.
John Torney argues he was only in a relationship with Emma Bates for a few weeks. Photo: AAP
Mr Torney’s barrister Hayden Rattray challenged that claim, arguing they had only been in a relationship for two to four weeks at the time of Ms Bates’ death.
De facto relationships were akin to marriage, whereas their relationship was “extraordinarily short-lived” and “profoundly unhealthy”, Mr Rattray said.
A jury could not find Mr Torney owed her a duty of care because they were not in a de facto relationship, the barrister said.
He also challenged the prosecution argument Mr Torney should have called an ambulance on the morning of April 22.
The court was told Ms Bates had a gash on her head, allegedly caused by Mr Torney, and was moaning, so Mr Torney threw her sugar tester towards her.
Mr Cookson argued Mr Torney breached his duty of care by not calling an ambulance when he realised she was not well.
“He doesn’t need to know what’s wrong, but he must have been aware something was wrong and he failed to act in the circumstances,” the prosecutor said.
Mr Rattray argued it was unclear when Ms Bates started experiencing the ketoacidosis, so it could not be said Mr Torney’s failure to call an ambulance caused her death.
“He had no reason to expect she would not wake up,” the barrister said.
Magistrate Stephen Ballek said he needed some time to consider whether the charge should be thrown out.
24°C